Preloader
Binokular Contact Us

Noise of Demonstrations, Crowd Clashes, and the Crisis of Representation

Jakarta suddenly roared on August 25 when a mass rally calling itself the “Indonesian People’s Revolution” filled the grounds of the DPR/MPR building. Heidegger once wrote in his essay Building, Dwelling, Thinking: “A building becomes a home not because it stands, but because it becomes a dwelling full of meaning.” Yet the grand parliament building is now seen by the people as meaningless. Flags flew, fists were raised, banners stretched out, and chants echoed. But what was more powerful than the street shouts was their resonance in the digital realm, generating over 57 million interactions on social media—proof that today’s revolutions come not only from bodies in the streets but also from fingers typing online.

This public anger did not come out of nowhere. It was an accumulation of long-standing disappointment: rising rice prices and basic necessities, lack of access to jobs, declining purchasing power, and unreasonable tax regulations—all of which added salt to a deep wound.

The List of Controversial Taxes

VAT 11% (up from 10%)April 1, 2022Law No. 7/2021 on Tax Regulation Harmonization (UU HPP)
Fintech & Crypto TaxMay 1, 2022Ministry of Finance Regulation No. 68/PMK.03/2022
Entertainment Tax 40–75%Jan 1, 2024Law No. 1/2022 on Fiscal Relations
BPJS Health Standard Class Fee (KRIS)July 1, 2025Presidential Decree No. 59/2024
Online Transaction Taxrevoked by Ministerial Regulation No. 12/PMK.010/2019Ministry of Finance Regulation. No. 210/PMK.010/2018

Most recently, following the issue of adulterated rice, the National Food Agency (Bapanas) raised the ceiling price for medium rice to Rp 13,000/kg. In 10 provinces, average rice prices already exceeded this ceiling, with North Sulawesi recording the highest disparity—16.15% above the regulated ceiling.

Unemployment and mass layoffs added fuel to the fire. The Ministry of Manpower recorded 1,570 industrial disputes in the first half of 2025, with 1,139 being layoffs. West Java had the highest share at 29.07%.

The IMF, in its April 2025 World Economic Forum Outlook, reported Indonesia’s unemployment rate at 5%, up from 4.9% in 2024 and projected to reach 5.1% in 2026—7th highest in Asia and the highest in Southeast Asia.

These wounds were deepened when DPR elites planned to increase housing allowances, confirming Tocqueville’s words in Democracy in America: “People don’t revolt because life is hard, but because they feel treated worse than they deserve.”

Journalists Record Events, Netizens Create Meaning

Thus began this week’s episode: people’s voices moving across spaces. On the streets—banners, chants, and stomping feet. In mainstream media and online, waves of words refusing silence.

Binokular’s Newstensity tool recorded 4,853 news articles from Aug 24–26, peaking on the 25th when the protest occurred. Most coverage (74%) carried negative sentiment: issues of DPR’s allowance hike, arrests of demonstrators, journalist intimidation, calls to dissolve parliament, traffic jams, and property damage.

Meanwhile, Socindex captured 106,756 social media conversations with 57.5 million engagements across Twitter/X, Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, and YouTube. Produced by 2,764 accounts and 4,739 posts, the discourse leaned negative and neutral. Bot detection showed 48% human-driven activity, proving organic public anger rather than artificial manipulation.

Emotion analysis revealed anger and anticipation dominated—echoing Castells’ thesis in Networks of Outrage and Hope that digital demonstrations form horizontal networks of rage and vision.

Demonstrations as Ritual Healing

Before today’s digital age, Michel Foucault stressed that power operates not only through institutions but through bodies. Demonstrations are bodily resistance: standing under the sun, marching against tear gas, pushing against parliament’s concrete fences. These bodies proclaim: “We refuse to be silenced.”

On social media, Jacques Lacan’s psychoanalysis applies: the symbolic order of parliament—rules, procedures, sessions—cannot fully capture the Real of people’s suffering: rising prices, low wages, injustice. Protests, then, are eruptions of the Real: voices breaking through state symbols. Every post becomes a digital ceremony, every comment a chant, every hashtag a symbolic flag.

Yet police responded with discriminatory force. Word clouds highlighted terms like “gas,” “riot police,” “retreat,” “water cannon,” and “beaten.” LBH Jakarta reported 370 arrests, including 200 minors; KPAI confirmed 203 children detained. Here, clashes reflected the breakdown of communication between people and state.

From a psychoanalytic lens, social trauma repeats. Each generation of Indonesian students has taken to the streets—1966, 1998, 2025. Because collective wounds never heal, protests become recurring rituals of unfinished healing.

Epilogue

The August 25 protest is a mirror: Indonesia’s democracy is being tested. We have institutions, procedures, and laws—but do we still have trust? Parliament’s existence is constitutional, but its moral legitimacy depends on returning to serve the people, shedding privilege, and reclaiming true representation.

Without reform, transparency, and courage to put the people first, the gap will widen. Cries of “Dissolve Parliament!” will echo from the streets, into media headlines, and across the digital realm.

Plato once asked in Republic: “Who will guard the guardians?” Today, Indonesians answer: “We ourselves will guard them—with voices, hashtags, protests, and resistance.”

As Pramoedya Ananta Toer’s Bumi Manusia reminds us: “We have resisted, as best, as honorably as we could.”

Or, echoing the film Olympus Has Fallen (2013), where U.S. Secretary of State Ruth McMillan, bloodied but unbroken, said: “We may meet our Creator today. But one thing I don’t want on my tombstone: She died without resisting.”

Writer: Hans Hayon (Newstensity), Ilustrator: Aan K. Riyadi

Other Analysis

QRIS, from Traditional Markets to the Global Stage

The lively atmosphere of Gamping Market, Yogyakarta, had begun to fade that morning. Several stalls stood empty as their owners,…

Rewriting History in the Public Eye: Renewal or Distortion of Facts?

The Red-and-White Cabinet’s programs never fail to capture public attention. One of them is the history rewriting project initiated by…

Setya Novanto Granted Conditional Release, Anti-Corruption Commitment Questioned

August 17, Indonesia’s Independence Day, is a joyful occasion for all Indonesians—including prisoners. On this day, the government grants sentence…

Sudewo and the Political Storm in Pati: From Property Tax Hike to 100,000 Protesters

Early August 2025 turned into a heated month in Pati Regency—not due to weather, but because political tensions erupted in…

Merah Putih: One for All; Half-Baked Nationalism

The animated film Merah Putih: One for All was launched in August 2025, timed to coincide with Indonesia’s 80th Independence…

The “Sound Horeg” Phenomenon: From Echo Chamber to Insight Chamber via Media Monitoring

A public debate has emerged around the presence of sound horeg (also called carnival sound), especially after the East Java…

Media Monitoring: Definition, Benefits, and Binokular Media Utama’s Solutions

In today’s digital age, millions of articles, videos, social-media posts, and news broadcasts go live every day. Governments, companies, and…

Ilustrasi satir presiden Prabowo Subianto sedang mengirim file berjudul “Data Penduduk Indonesia.xlsx” ke ponsel Donald Trump, menggambarkan isu keamanan data dalam konteks pengawasan media dan sosial.

Digital-Sovereignty Risks Behind the New U.S.–Indonesia Trade Deal

Indonesia’s data-security debate has flared again—this time over a clause in the newly minted trade pact with the United States…

Ilustrasi tangan menyusun balok huruf ESG (Environmental, Social, Governance) secara bertahap, menggambarkan proses membangun fondasi keberlanjutan yang stabil.

Understanding ESG: Definition, Functions, and the Role of Media Monitoring

Over the past few decades, growing awareness of sustainability has reshaped the way companies and investors evaluate business performance. Rising…

Tom Lembong Triumphs on Social Media

On a rather scorching Friday afternoon, 18 July 2025, Thomas Trikasih Lembong—better known as Tom Lembong— entered the Hatta Ali…